Skip to content

The Spare Key to Her

Chapter 3

Half Past Eight

Swipe left for the next chapter, right for the previous one

CHAPTER THREE
Half Past Eight

April arrived in Gull Harbor the way it always did, with a lot of noise and very little warmth: sudden downpours that blew in sideways from the bay, a few days of bright cold, and then the thick, dripping mildness of mud season, when the whole peninsula smelled of wet earth and woodsmoke and something green just starting to think about itself.

And somewhere in the first week of it, without anyone having decided it, Corinne’s life acquired a schedule.

Every morning at half past eight, there was the crunch of tires on the gravel drive, a door slamming, and footsteps on the porch. Then three sharp raps, a pause, and one light tap, like the last note of a tune.

Emory never came empty-handed. He had a gift for it, an almost professional gift. He always had a reason, and the reason was always so good that she’d run out of objections by the time she’d opened the door.

On Monday he brought a dozen blue-shelled eggs from a neighbor’s hens (“They lay the color of a robin’s egg, I swear, it’s unnatural, the hens are very proud”). On Wednesday it was two oak boards, kiln-dried, to shore up the study bookshelf, where he informed her gravely that a two-degree tilt would, over a decade, warp the spines of every antique dictionary she owned. On Friday he showed up with a sack of seasoned pine, smelling of resin, and a bundle of kindling tied with twine, and by the time she’d found her slippers he had the old woodstove in the front room swept, laid and lit, so that the whole room glowed gold before the morning fog had a chance to find the windows.

“You don’t have to come every day,” she told him, in the second week of April, as he crouched at the front window with a rag, scrubbing salt-frost off the frame. She’d tried to say it lightly. It came out like a person asking permission. “Really. I don’t want to take up your time.”

He looked up, and the smile came, as it always did, with that slightly crooked tooth. “I start at the boatyard at five,” he said. “By the time I’m through, the road from the dock passes right by your gate. It’s on my way.”

“It is not on your way. Port Ellis is the other direction.”

“It’s on a way.”

“That’s not the same thing.”

“It’s on a very scenic way.” He wrung out the rag. “Cor. Honestly. If it’s a bother, you only have to tell me. I’ll stop. I won’t be offended. I’ll sit in my truck at the end of the road with a thermos and go quietly insane, but I won’t be offended.”

“I didn’t say it was a bother.”

“No,” he agreed. “You said you didn’t want to take up my time. I’m telling you my time is mine, and I’m spending it.” He reached up and shoved the sash open a notch to let the damp air through, and added, without any change of tone: “Also, the stove’s finicky. If you try to light it without me, you’ll singe your eyebrows.”

She opened her mouth to argue. She closed it.

He was right about the stove.

* * *

The truth was, she was getting used to it. That was the unsettling part. She’d arrived in Gull Harbor braced for isolation, and instead she found that the huge, silent, stone-bound house had, in two weeks, grown a soundtrack: the rasp of a hand plane on the back porch, the dull knock of a hammer, the hiss and crackle of kindling taking light. And over everything, low and wordless, Emory’s humming. He hummed while he worked, absently, a tune she couldn’t place, something slow and swaying with the rhythm of an oar, that wandered up and down through five or six notes and never seemed to arrive anywhere. He never seemed to know he was doing it.

By the middle of the month, the Skau book had picked up speed.

She worked at the oak desk with the window open an inch and the sea air stirring the pages. Emory worked in the same room more often than not, sanding a bracket or reattaching a curtain rod, and somewhere around the third day it had stopped being strange and become simply a thing that happened, like weather. One afternoon, she found herself saying aloud, to nobody, to the screen, “He uses these punishing little sentences. Look at this. ‘She did not come. The tide did.’ He’s saying everything by saying nothing. Every semicolon is somebody holding their breath.”

“Does Norwegian have more words for fear than English?” Emory asked, from the window.

She turned, surprised. She’d forgotten he was there. He was perched on the sill with a plane in one hand, a small curl of pale wood hanging from the blade, and he was looking at her with perfect, undivided interest, as if she’d just said something he’d been waiting all his life to hear.

“Not more words, exactly,” she said slowly. “It’s how they build the sentence around the fear. You know — in English we explain. ‘She was afraid, because the door had been left open.’ In Norwegian you can just say the door. Leave it there. Let the silence do the explaining.” She picked up her pencil, pointed at a penciled note in the margin. “They build atmosphere with absences. Like — all right, take ‘good morning.’ God morgen. It sounds so clean, doesn’t it? So crisp. Or takk, thank you. One syllable. It’s complete.”

“God morgen,” Emory said.

He’d said it with the throat-scrape of the G, the long open o, the soft closing n, exactly as she’d said it, exactly as she said it to the cormorants on the rocks. It was perfect. She actually blinked.

“Have you studied Norwegian?”

“Never.”

“That’s impossible. That was flawless.”

“I just listen to you,” he said, a little sheepish, rubbing the back of his neck with a floury hand. “You say it under your breath a lot. When you’re working. I think it’s — I must have just absorbed it.”

“You absorbed it in four days.”

“I’m an excellent sponge.” He grinned. “Say another one.”

She said another one. And another. By the end of the week, he was greeting her at the door every morning with a solemn god morgen, and responding to every cup of tea with takk skal du ha, which she’d taught him as a joke and which he’d learned the way he learned everything, entirely, at once, as if someone had put a recording on a tape and he’d played it back. It was almost uncanny. It was also, she had to admit, very charming. She had never had a student before who wanted so much to get it right.

On the fourth day, his keys fell out of his vest pocket as he leaned over the window latch, and landed with a jingle on the desk beside her laptop.

“Sorry.” He scooped them up. They were on a plain steel ring, nothing sentimental: the truck key, a couple of brass ones, a small silver one for something with a padlock. She noticed, because she noticed that sort of thing, that two of the brass keys were identical. They lay side by side on the ring, same cut, same shine, same tiny nick near the bow.

“Why do you have two of the same key?”

“Habit.” He turned the ring over in his fingers. “It’s my dad’s rule. He used to say a man with one key has none. You lose it, you break it, someone borrows it, and there you are, standing in the rain.” He shrugged, with an odd, lopsided, private smile. “I keep a spare of everything. It’s a — condition.”

“I think that’s lovely.”

“Do you?”

“I think it’s very responsible,” she said. “I’ve lost eleven sets of keys since I turned thirty. I’d have saved a fortune.”

“Then you should have a spare.” He said it lightly. “I could cut you one for every door in the house.”

“Don’t you dare. I’d lose them all.”

* * *

She’d been in Port Ellis three times since arriving, and each time had resulted in a conversation with Mrs. Dunphy.

Mrs. Dunphy ran the post-office counter at the general store, a small wooden window at the back, between the fishing tackle and the pickled eggs. She was a plump woman of about seventy with a lavender cardigan, bifocals on a chain, and an unfailingly pleasant voice, and she had the incurable gift of being interested in everything. She remembered the name of every person who’d ever mailed a package in Gull Harbor, and what was in it, and who it was for, and why that was a strange thing to send.

“Aldermere,” she said, on the third trip, weighing a manila envelope on the postal scale and peering over her bifocals. “That’s a Scotch name. Are you any relation to the Aldermeres in Camden? The ones with the dairy?”

“I don’t think so. My mother was a Lind. Norwegian.”

“Well, isn’t that nice! Norwegian. We had a Norwegian man at church once, a Mr. Olsen, who made the most wonderful little cookies. They had a name. They were very hard to pronounce.” A stamp came down with a thunk. “You’re the lady at the Fennimore place.”

“That’s me.”

“All alone out there?”

“I’ve got the lighthouse for company.”

“Oh, that old thing.” Mrs. Dunphy lowered her voice, with relish. “They say old Captain Hal’s wife used to walk the gallery on foggy nights, waiting for him to come in. Very romantic. Died of pneumonia, poor thing.” The bifocals glinted. “That Wolcott boy has been out at the Fennimore place every day, hasn’t he? Philippa Wolcott’s son? I saw his truck on the Route 1 turnoff twice this week.”

Corinne kept her expression perfectly pleasant. “He’s been helping with some repairs. He’s very kind.”

“Oh, he is, he’s a lovely boy. It was such a sad thing about his father. And at that age! He was fifteen, you know. Of course you know, you’re Pip’s friend. I met her once, at a funeral, a very sad business.” She patted Corinne’s envelope with a plump hand. “He’ll make some lucky girl a very good husband. Very attentive. You can always tell with the attentive ones.”

“Mrs. Dunphy,” said Corinne, “I’m thirty-eight years old and I was his mother’s roommate.”

“I’m sure you were, dear.” She handed over the receipt with a bright, wicked, absolutely unrepentant smile. “I’m only saying.”

Corinne drove home with the windows down and her cheeks warm and was in a very bad mood for exactly as long as it took her to turn into the drive and see the old green pickup, and the porch, and a large figure in flannel stacking wood against the wall, who raised one arm and waved.

She waved back. She had not, she noticed, decided to.

* * *

On the third Tuesday in April, a little after two o’clock, Graham called.

She saw his name light up on her phone, resting on the corner of the desk, and felt her whole body go cold. She watched it ring three times. Then, because she was thirty-eight and an adult, and because she had a mortgage-sized retirement split riding on whatever he was about to say, she picked it up.

“Corinne.” His voice came over the speaker dry and cold, and with a particular little edge she remembered. “Your lawyer just sent a notice. She wants a full audit of the Portland fund. What kind of game do you think you’re playing? We settled this. In court. Last month.”

“It’s not a game, Graham.” Her voice was steadier than her hand. “Dana found some discrepancies in the Q4 numbers. Shares that weren’t disclosed. That’s marital property. You were required to —”

“Marital property.” He laughed, a short, ugly sound. “Is that what they’re calling it? Are you sitting up there in some rented hovel, drinking tea, writing yourself little stories about being wronged? Who do you think supported you for twelve years? Who do you think paid for four hospital stays? You couldn’t even give this family a child, Corinne, and now you want to bleed me for every —”

The room went very quiet.

It always did, at that sentence. Every time. In twelve years of marriage there had been maybe a hundred fights, and she knew, now, with the clarity of an autopsy, that every one had been designed to arrive here. It didn’t matter what they’d started about, the dishes, the money, the way she’d looked at someone at a party. By the end, it came around to the four silent hospital rooms and the four small things nobody had named, and the fact that he’d had it ready, polished, loaded, a stone in his pocket. He’d always known exactly where it would hurt.

“Don’t,” she said. It came out a whisper, nothing like the voice she’d meant. “Don’t you ever bring that up again.”

“Let me tell you something, Corinne, I don’t care what you —”

She ended the call.

She hadn’t decided to. Her thumb simply did it. She dropped the phone on the desk, face down, and put both hands over her face, and tried to breathe. It wasn’t working. There was a hard wet knot in her throat and her shoulders were doing something she didn’t have any say over, and she could hear her own breath dragging in and out like a saw in damp wood. Four. She had never said it aloud to anyone but a doctor. She would not, she told herself, cry in a rented house in the middle of the afternoon in front of —

Footsteps. Soft, on the floorboards.

She jerked her head up.

Emory stood in the study doorway in a thin gray sweater, holding a small wooden tray.

She hadn’t heard him come in. She hadn’t known he’d been in; the truck wasn’t in the drive, she’d have sworn it. But there he was, in the middle of the hallway, with a look on his face she’d never seen before, a kind of fixed, careful stillness, like a man carrying a very full glass across a very long room.

He didn’t ask who had called. He didn’t ask why she was shaking. He didn’t ask anything at all, and there wasn’t a drop of pity in his face; it would have been unbearable if there had been. He only crossed the room in four long strides and set the tray down on the corner of the desk, and she saw what was on it: a white mug, steaming, the chamomile, the honey stirred in. Two spoonfuls. And beside it, on a saucer, three warm, lopsided oatmeal cookies.

“Hot tea,” he said quietly.

She took the mug. Warmth poured up through the porcelain into her cold hands like a held breath finally let out. She looked down into it, and then up at him, and had to blink hard.

“I’m sorry,” she said. Her voice cracked on it. “You shouldn’t have — I didn’t want you to see that.”

“I’m not sorry I saw it.”

He didn’t step back. He didn’t crowd in, either. He stood a few feet away, hands loose at his sides, as if he understood precisely how much room she needed and meant to give her exactly that, no more, no less. After a moment he slid the plate of cookies an inch toward her with one finger.

“Eat one,” he said. “They’re terrible. I burned the first batch. It’s better to be distracted by something terrible.”

A laugh escaped her, wet and cracked and entirely involuntary. She took a cookie. It was, in fact, terrible, hard on the edges and soft in the middle, and she ate the whole thing.

“You don’t have to be okay,” Emory said, in that same low, unhurried voice. “Not today.”

She froze with the second cookie halfway to her mouth.

There was a very faint ringing in her ears. It was the oddest sensation: as though someone had struck a bell at the far end of a long corridor, and the sound was only just reaching her. She knew that sentence. She knew the shape of it, the cadence, the little drop at the end. She’d said it, hadn’t she? To someone? Somewhere? She couldn’t think who. She’d said it to a number of people over the years; it was the sort of thing she said.

“Where did you hear that?” she asked.

For a moment he didn’t answer. Then he gave her a small, half-rueful smile, and she could have sworn something moved behind it. “Somebody told me once. It stuck.”

“It’s a good one.”

“It’s the best one,” said Emory. “I think about it a lot.”

She looked at him over the rim of the mug. Something in her chest, some old stiff muscle, eased a fraction.

“I’m not very good at being looked after,” she said. It came out like a confession.

“I know,” he said. “It’s all right. You’ll get better at it.”

* * *

That evening, over an hour after he’d left, her phone rang again, and this time the screen said PIP.

“Cor!” Pip’s voice crackled out of the speaker, lively and bright, the honk and rumble of Portland rush hour just audible behind it. “Are you alive? Are you eating? Have you fallen off the cliff?”

“I’m alive.” She curled her feet up under her on the sofa, the tea long cold in the mug beside her. “I’m eating. Somebody keeps stocking my fridge, so I haven’t had to buy a thing. I suspect you.”

“I don’t know what you mean,” said Pip, with perfect innocence, and then, dropping the innocence all at once: “How’s my kid?”

“Your kid?”

“Emory.” A faint, odd hesitation. “He told me he’s been dropping by. Fixing things. I said, don’t bother her, she’s working. But you know him. He’s got a thing about fixing.”

“Bothering me? Pip, he’s been a godsend. He fixed the shutters. He fixed the bookshelf, the step, the door, the stove. He brought me eggs from some very proud chickens.” She laughed. “He’s remarkably thoughtful.”

There was a silence on the line.

Not a long one. Perhaps two full seconds. But Pip, in twenty years, had never gone quiet in the middle of a sentence. Corinne said, “Pip? Are you still there?”

“Yeah. Yeah, I’m here.” A breath. “He’s thoughtful. Sometimes — to a fault, I think. It’s just that —” Another short, unfamiliar pause, in which she heard her friend choose a different sentence from the one she’d started. “I just don’t want him crowding you. He gets very focused, you know, once he’s decided something. If he ever gets to be too much, you tell him to go home. All right? You don’t have to be polite about it.”

“He’s very respectful, Pip.”

“I’m sure he is.”

“He is Pip’s son,” said Corinne firmly. “I’m in no danger of being crowded by a boy I once taught to use a fork.”

Pip laughed then, a real laugh, quick and warm, and the strange stiffness went out of the line, and they spent the next twenty minutes on other things: the clinic’s budget, a donor Pip loathed, the first sign of tulips on Beech Street. When they hung up, Corinne sat with the phone in her lap and the quiet pressing at the windows.

She was thinking about the afternoon.

Specifically, she was thinking that Graham had called at two o’clock. That the truck hadn’t been in the drive. That Emory, who ran his hours by the boatyard clock and whose time she’d been told, repeatedly, was his own, had walked into her study, with a tray, with tea already steeped, in the thirty seconds after the call ended.

It nagged at her, like a splinter.

He’s a volunteer EMT, she told herself, with the reasonable voice she’d been using for twelve years. He’s trained to read people. He’s got an ear for distress. It’s his job. He probably heard a raised voice through the open window and came to check. The window had been open an inch. It was a perfectly good explanation.

She turned off the lamp and went upstairs.

On the landing, she passed the tall mirror she’d hardly looked at in a month, and glanced at it, absently, and stopped. A woman looked back at her: dusty-blue blouse, a tortoiseshell clip pinning her hair up, a touch of tinted balm on her lips. She’d put on the blouse that morning, hadn’t she? She’d done her hair. She’d put on lip balm. She’d done all this before nine o’clock, for a day of working alone in a house at the end of the earth.

For the first time since the divorce, she examined the question seriously.

Since when did she get dressed for the mailman?

She stood there for a long moment, looking at the woman in the glass, who looked back, a little wide-eyed, a little flushed, and about ten years younger than she’d had any right to look.

“Oh, no,” Corinne said aloud, softly, to nobody. “No, no. Absolutely not.”

And she went to bed, and lay in the dark listening to the sea, and did not, under any circumstances, think about half past eight.

How did this moment feel?

Choose any reactions that fit.

Comments (0)

Log in to write a comment…

Loading comments…