Skip to content

Numbers Never Lie

Chapter 1

Dahlia

Swipe left for the next chapter, right for the previous one

Chapter 1: Dahlia

Elspeth

White has no smell, but this place does.

Diluted bleach. Wet wool where snow has melted into someone's coat. And under both, a thin synthetic sweetness, the kind they spray to cover what a body leaves behind when it has been kept too long in one room.

I open my eyes.

A flat gray ceiling. Recessed lights, flicker-free, set low enough to soothe and high enough to never let you sleep properly. Someone calculated that. Someone always calculates.

One. Two. Three. Four.

I count the ceiling tiles because counting is the only thing in this room that has not been taken from me yet. Sixty-four tiles, sixty centimeters a side. Call it fifteen square meters of floor. No sharp corners anywhere. Every wall edge has been rounded off in pale plaster, as though the architect expected the residents to try to cut themselves on the geometry.

"Dahlia?"

The voice comes from my right. Deep. Level. It has the rhythm of a pendulum, and it is not meant to wake me. It is meant to slide in under the part of the brain that panics and lower its frequency.

I turn my head. Something in my neck objects. A hot wire at the third vertebra.

A man sits in an ash-gray leather armchair beside the bed. White shirt, silver cufflinks, charcoal waistcoat, a Windsor knot with no wrinkle in it. Forty, give or take. A square jaw above hollow cheeks, ash-colored hair combed straight back. Light gray eyes, the color of the Hudson on a foggy morning in February.

"Do you know where you are?" he asks.

Handmade, I think. Every gesture on him is handmade.

I don't answer. My throat is a dry well with quicklime in the bottom.

"You're at the Aldenmoor Institute." He holds a black notebook in one hand and a fountain pen in the other. Montblanc, the fat one. "I'm Dr. Ambrose Kestrel, the clinical director. You've been with us for a little while."

I look down.

Two hands lie on a coarse gray blanket. The left is bare. But around the base of the ring finger there is a band of skin four millimeters wide, paler than the rest, faintly sunken. The ghost of metal. Skin that has not seen sunlight in a very long time.

Seven years? Eight?

I lift the hand close to my face and press the thumb against the pale strip. The fine movements come easily. Thumb and index finger meet with a precision the right hand can't match when I try it, and I try it, because testing is what I do. The right is clumsy. Willing, but clumsy.

I am left-handed.

"Dahlia." He says it again, gently, the way you say a word to a dog until the dog decides it is a name. "Do you remember your name?"

Dahlia Reeve.

It drops into my head like a stone into a well so deep there is no splash. No ripple. The name sits on me the way an oversized coat sits on a coat rack. It has nothing to do with the frame underneath.

"I..." My voice comes out as a scrape. "I don't..."

I reach up and touch my hair. Dry. Brittle. It smells of cheap chemical bleach. A strand falls across my eye, and it is black, flat, painted black. But when I sweep my fingers back to the scalp and tilt my head under the light, I see the roots. Honey-brown. An inch of my own color, growing out underneath the lie.

My hair was a different color. My hand wore a ring.

Those are two facts. I add them to the column.

"Don't be alarmed." Kestrel stands. His shoes make no sound on the vinyl floor. He approaches the bed and stops one-point-two meters away, exactly. The standard safe distance: close enough to control, far enough that a patient doesn't feel hunted. "The confusion is a side effect of the treatment. A short course of electroconvulsive therapy and some heavy sedation. Your short-term memory is disrupted. It will settle."

"What happened?" I ask. My eyes count the buttons on his waistcoat while I ask it. Five. The fourth is stitched a fraction of a millimeter off true.

He looks at me with a measured portion of pity. Then his right hand rises, two fingers settle on the silver cufflink at his left wrist, and he turns it.

A small turn. Fifteen degrees. Neat.

Tell.

I file it the way I file everything. A man who adjusts his cufflink just before he tells you what happened is not telling you what happened. He is restructuring it.

"There was a serious incident at the Lake Verrin house," he says. His voice drops a pitch, becoming warm and comforting and entirely fake. "Three weeks ago. You suffered a dissociative episode. In a state of paranoid psychosis, you had a violent confrontation with your husband."

"My husband."

"Conrad. Conrad Marrow."

The name goes into my ear like a nail.

A white-hot line runs through my left temple, fast as a blade passing through gelatin, and then it is gone and the place where it was feels hollow. No face comes with it. No voice. Only cold, and the smell of cedarwood climbing up the back of my nose, and the crisp little snap of a Zippo lighter opening in the dark.

Snap.

"You stabbed him with a kitchen knife," Kestrel says. He is watching my pupils. "Then, in a panic to destroy the evidence, you set the house on fire. The State Police found you on the shore with soot on your face, holding a fence stake, screaming. Conrad's body was recovered, badly burned. He was identified from dental records."

He lets the silence sit. He is good at that. He lets it settle into the place where a memory ought to be and grow roots there.

"The family has agreed not to press charges," he adds, almost tender, "provided you're kept safely away from the world and treated here for as long as it takes. You are a prisoner of your own mind, Dahlia. I am here to help you out of it."

I look at him. My face stays as flat as the ceiling.

Here is the problem. How does a woman react when she is told she has killed her husband, burned his body, and lost her mind? Weeping, presumably. Dilated pupils. Fast breathing. Trembling hands. A standard set of inputs. I have testified in front of juries who needed to be told what grief looks like. I know the set.

So I run it.

I drop my shoulders. I lower my chin two centimeters and look up at him through the black hair. I let my pulse jump in my throat, where he can see it, and I force my breath to come short and ragged. I bring both hands up and scrape my right thumbnail across the white strip on the left ring finger until the skin goes red, then raw, then beads of blood come up through it.

"No." My voice shakes at the exact pitch of someone about to come apart. "No, that isn't... I didn't... I'm not..."

Kestrel watches. Something in his eyes eases. It is the satisfaction of a builder who has laid the first course of brick and finds the line is true. He flips open the black notebook and writes.

I can read his handwriting upside down. A forensic accountant reads everything upside down eventually.

Patient D. Reeve. Trauma disclosure processed. Denial, paranoid ideation, secondary panic. Normal progression.

The door opens without a knock.

A woman steps in, mid-fifties, in a blue-gray nurse's tunic. Her hair is scraped into a bun so tight it pulls the skin at her temples. Deep lines run down the sides of her neck. She has the eyes of someone who has seen too much of other people's madness to believe in much besides the schedule.

"Dr. Kestrel," she says. "Dahlia's morning medication."

On a small steel tray she carries a paper cup of water and a clear plastic cup with two pills. A pale yellow oval. A dark blue capsule.

"Thank you, Nurse Sorrell."

Bridget Sorrell. The name tag says so. She doesn't look at my face. She hands me the water and holds the plastic cup out at the level of my chin, and when she speaks, her voice is a rasp laced with tobacco and peppermint gum. The gum is a poor disguise.

"Take them."

I study the pills.

The yellow one is haloperidol, or its cousin olanzapine: an antipsychotic strong enough to flatten the affect and fog the cortex. The blue is a benzodiazepine. It loosens the nerves and dissolves the will to resist.

How do I know that?

The names come up in my head as easily as breathing. As naturally as measuring a room by its ceiling tiles. This is stored knowledge, installed years ago. Dahlia Reeve, whoever she is, would not know the difference between haloperidol and plant fertilizer.

"Dahlia," Kestrel murmurs. "They'll keep the nightmares from tearing you apart. Be a good girl."

I reach out with my left hand. Two fingers shake as they close around the cup. I tip both pills into my mouth, quick and clean, and in the instant my head tilts back and the paper cup meets my lip, my tongue does something I did not tell it to do.

It curls back. It hooks the yellow oval and the blue capsule past my lower teeth and tucks them into the pocket between the back gum and the inside of my left cheek, as smoothly as a card dealer palming an ace. A motion so practiced it startles me.

I swallow water. A big gulp. Hard.

"Open," says Nurse Sorrell.

I open. Tongue flat. Cheeks slack. She clicks on a penlight and sweeps it across my mouth. Pink tissue. Saliva. Nothing.

"Good girl."

She straightens and gathers the tray. Kestrel, standing, smiles his thin smile, which does not reach the gray of his eyes.

"Very good, Dahlia. Submission is the first step to healing." He clips the Montblanc into his breast pocket. "Tomorrow we begin with the evidence, so that you can see what you're recovering from. After that, hypnotherapy. I'll help you clear away the last of the fragments."

He steps closer, breaking his own rule of one-point-two meters. His fingers are long and cold. They brush my forehead and tuck a black strand behind my ear, and the touch raises every hair on my arms. My stomach turns over. I clamp down on it so hard that no muscle in my face moves.

"You're safe here," he says, and the affection in his voice is so complete it is almost sickening. "I'm the only one who will ever keep you that way."

He turns and goes out. Nurse Sorrell follows. The steel door closes with a dry, heavy thud, and from somewhere in the frame, a lock slides home.

Click.

I lie still.

One minute. Two. Three. Their footsteps cross the corridor, thin out, and dissolve into the soundproofing. The silence that comes after is not silence. It has a hum in it, the hum of ventilation and fluorescent ballasts and a building full of people trying not to be heard.

I sit up.

I tilt my head left, push two fingers into my cheek, and hook the pills out. Both intact, slick with saliva, the yellow one already beginning to chalk at its edge. I tear a scrap off the paper cup I hid under the blanket and wrap them, and then I slide the tiny packet into the seam under the rubber mattress.

Two pills. A first entry.

They designed this place well. I give them that. They made one error.

They believed that if they drugged me, bleached my hair, took my name, and poured a murder into my head, they could wipe the brain clean. But a brain like mine does not run on feeling. It runs on tallies. On muscle memory and arithmetic, on the one rhythm no sedative can bend: the habit of checking whether the books balance.

I stand. My bare feet find the freezing floor.

I walk.

From the bed's edge toward the far wall. One. Two. Three. Four. Five.

At the wall there is a mirror, acrylic and shatterproof, bolted flush. I stop.

The woman in it has shoulder-length hair cut by a stranger and dyed the color of a crow. Her face is gaunt, her skin gray from the lack of sun, her eyes sunk. But the eyes are not a madwoman's. They are deep brown and sharp, and in them sits a clarity so cold it surprises me.

I look down at my left hand.

Numbers never lie, Els.

It comes unbidden, in a voice that is not Kestrel's. Lower. Roughened by decades of cigarettes. A voice that loved me and used to say this at the end of every audit, when the last column foots and the checkmarks line up. It carries absolute trust.

Els.

Elspeth.

My name is not Dahlia.

My name is Elspeth Calder Marrow.

I am a forensic accountant. I find the one wrong digit in ten thousand pages. I follow the money to the place where it is bleeding, and I put my finger on the wound and say: here. For twelve years that has been my work, and for twelve years it has been the only work I have been good at.

I did not kill anyone.

I'm the one they meant to bury.

I turn to the window. It is set high in the east wall, forty centimeters by eighty, and across it run five white-painted iron bars sunk into the concrete. Beyond them, the Hudson Valley's maples are going dark red, the color of old blood, and the wind is stripping them one leaf at a time.

I cross the room to it.

One. Two. Three. Four. Five. Six. Seven. Eight. Nine. Ten. Eleven. Twelve. Thirteen. Fourteen.

Fourteen steps.

I smile. It has no joy in it at all. It is the smile of New York ice in January.

Dr. Ambrose Kestrel thinks he is holding a broken doll. He thinks he is the only player in this white room.

He has no idea that the game has started. And I will count every step he takes until he opens this cage himself.

Next ChapterChapter 2: The Rules of Aldenmoor

How did this moment feel?

Choose any reactions that fit.

Comments (0)

Log in to write a comment…

Loading comments…